Planned Economy is Constent

Under a Planned Economy, Labour Vochers, money, etc. are unlimited and have a constent value of 1.00 doller and it never changes 1.00 doller is always 1.00 doller, the goverment has unlmited money.

Supply and Demand do not apply, capitalism is based on it and socialism is based on a fixed price system

if the goverment has unlimited money won't it like drop in value becuse there is more of it?
I mean, evrybody likes, ummm paper, were woould we be without paper?
it's easy to make and comes in huge qantaties so it's cheap but still we can't live without it, but it has littel value to use due to the huge ammunts.

even in a communist or fixed system pepole will take things for granted and will slowly stop working.

no, supply and demand do not apply, prices and value are fixed

cary jebus wrote:

no, supply and demand do not apply, prices and value are fixed

umm does not matterr in pepoles eyes theyer value will diminish.
state will make lots of stuff for the pepole but the pepole want more than that then you get a black market.

mattabesta wrote:

cary jebus wrote:

no, supply and demand do not apply, prices and value are fixed

umm does not matterr in pepoles eyes theyer value will diminish.
state will make lots of stuff for the pepole but the pepole want more than that then you get a black market.

black marketing is a big crime, its hard to pull off big crimes...

cary jebus wrote:

mattabesta wrote:

cary jebus wrote:

no, supply and demand do not apply, prices and value are fixed

umm does not matterr in pepoles eyes theyer value will diminish.
state will make lots of stuff for the pepole but the pepole want more than that then you get a black market.

black marketing is a big crime, its hard to pull off big crimes...

not really cuba has a reaLLY,REALLY BIG ONE.

mattabesta wrote:

cary jebus wrote:

mattabesta wrote:

cary jebus wrote:

no, supply and demand do not apply, prices and value are fixed

umm does not matterr in pepoles eyes theyer value will diminish.
state will make lots of stuff for the pepole but the pepole want more than that then you get a black market.

black marketing is a big crime, its hard to pull off big crimes...

not really cuba has a reaLLY,REALLY BIG ONE.

correct, because there law enforcement sucks.

Also why owuld they want more, with unlmited money the state can always fill the demand for it.

Matt, I think you misunderstand. There won't be unlimited money in circulation, but there is no limit to how much money can be made. The amount of money increases if there are more laborers. However, prices will NOT be constant in socialism. If there is technology to make faster production of something the price of it will drop. The price of a commodity is equal to the amount of labor used to produce it, because prices will correspond to the labor theory of value. Workers will get paid according to how much they work, but will not get paid the full value of their labor because some tax money will need to be taken out to pay for education, old people's homes, etc.

Pannekoek wrote:

Matt, I think you misunderstand. There won't be unlimited money in circulation, but there is no limit to how much money can be made. The amount of money increases if there are more laborers. However, prices will NOT be constant in socialism. If there is technology to make faster production of something the price of it will drop. The price of a commodity is equal to the amount of labor used to produce it, because prices will correspond to the labor theory of value. Workers will get paid according to how much they work, but will not get paid the full value of their labor because some tax money will need to be taken out to pay for education, old people's homes, etc.

no, no money will need ot be taken out, the goverment has unlimited money.

and no it wont, the price is fixed PERIOD.

Quote :

the price is fixed PERIOD

Trust me on this one, buddy. If something takes 10 hours to make it will cost much more than if it took 1 hour to make. You obviously don't understand the labor theory of value.

Quote :

the goverment has unlimited money

The government won't have infinite money sitting in a safe. However, it can potentially make as much money as it wants.

Pannekoek wrote:

Quote :

the price is fixed PERIOD

Trust me on this one, buddy. If something takes 10 hours to make it will cost much more than if it took 1 hour to make. You obviously don't understand the labor theory of value.

Quote :

the goverment has unlimited money

The government won't have infinite money sitting in a safe. However, it can potentially make as much money as it wants.

yah ie, it can print all the cash it wantd

cary jebus wrote:

mattabesta wrote:

cary jebus wrote:

mattabesta wrote:

cary jebus wrote:

no, supply and demand do not apply, prices and value are fixed

umm does not matterr in pepoles eyes theyer value will diminish.
state will make lots of stuff for the pepole but the pepole want more than that then you get a black market.

black marketing is a big crime, its hard to pull off big crimes...

not really cuba has a reaLLY,REALLY BIG ONE.

correct, because there law enforcement sucks.

Also why owuld they want more, with unlmited money the state can always fill the demand for it.

how can they decide what the pepole want?
anyway it's not the law enforcement that sucks it's the 1.5 million pepole useing the black market.

mattabesta wrote:

cary jebus wrote:

mattabesta wrote:

cary jebus wrote:

mattabesta wrote:

cary jebus wrote:

no, supply and demand do not apply, prices and value are fixed

umm does not matterr in pepoles eyes theyer value will diminish.
state will make lots of stuff for the pepole but the pepole want more than that then you get a black market.

black marketing is a big crime, its hard to pull off big crimes...

not really cuba has a reaLLY,REALLY BIG ONE.

correct, because there law enforcement sucks.

Also why owuld they want more, with unlmited money the state can always fill the demand for it.

how can they decide what the pepole want?
anyway it's not the law enforcement that sucks it's the 1.5 million pepole useing the black market.

no the law enforcement is so entruisive htat people want ot "get back at the man"

cary jebus wrote:

mattabesta wrote:

cary jebus wrote:

mattabesta wrote:

cary jebus wrote:

mattabesta wrote:

cary jebus wrote:

no, supply and demand do not apply, prices and value are fixed

umm does not matterr in pepoles eyes theyer value will diminish.
state will make lots of stuff for the pepole but the pepole want more than that then you get a black market.

black marketing is a big crime, its hard to pull off big crimes...

not really cuba has a reaLLY,REALLY BIG ONE.

correct, because there law enforcement sucks.

Also why owuld they want more, with unlmited money the state can always fill the demand for it.

how can they decide what the pepole want?
anyway it's not the law enforcement that sucks it's the 1.5 million pepole useing the black market.

no the law enforcement is so entruisive htat people want ot "get back at the man"

Crime rates in Cuba remain significantly lower than many other major cities worldwide, with Cuban police acting strongly against any crime, particularly in Havana. Fidel Castro commented in 1998 that "The war against crime is also a war against the imperialist enemy."[3] Information on murder and rape crime statistics for the country have never been released by the government, however theft was estimated to be 6,531 cases in 1988, or 62 per 100,000 population.[4] The Cuban penal system contained 19,000 inmates in 1990, approximately 190 per 100,000.[4]

mattabesta wrote:

The Cuban penal system contained 19,000 inmates in 1990, approximately 190 per 100,000.[4]

The US penal system incarcerates...
Read and find out.

Pannekoek wrote:

Quote :

the price is fixed PERIOD

Trust me on this one, buddy. If something takes 10 hours to make it will cost much more than if it took 1 hour to make. You obviously don't understand the labor theory of value.

Simply put, the value of a commodity is determined by the amount of time socially necessary to produce it. Capitalist production is governed by the Law of Value.

Thanks, Oligarch.

Quote :

how can they decide what the pepole want?

The amount of money they print corresponds to the amount of labor being performed. The more labor, the more money in circulation.

oligarch wrote:

Pannekoek wrote:

Quote :

the price is fixed PERIOD

Trust me on this one, buddy. If something takes 10 hours to make it will cost much more than if it took 1 hour to make. You obviously don't understand the labor theory of value.

Simply put, the value of a commodity is determined by the amount of time socially necessary to produce it. Capitalist production is governed by the Law of Value.

correct, but money takes no time to make if you have infenet ammunts of it and that's why it becomes worthless.

There isn't infinite amounts of it in circulation.

mattabesta wrote:

oligarch wrote:

Pannekoek wrote:

Quote :

the price is fixed PERIOD

Trust me on this one, buddy. If something takes 10 hours to make it will cost much more than if it took 1 hour to make. You obviously don't understand the labor theory of value.

Simply put, the value of a commodity is determined by the amount of time socially necessary to produce it. Capitalist production is governed by the Law of Value.

correct, but money takes no time to make if you have infenet ammunts of it and that's why it becomes worthless.

no it dosnt, supply and demand do not apply. Therefor no matter how much you have or how many people want it, it ownt matter, what matters is tje need of it, in socialism things that are needed are free this includes some fun things because enjoyment is a need, as things become less needed the price goes up. goverment money is a need

Don't pay any attention to cary jebus, he/she does not know what he/she is talking about.

Pannekoek wrote:

Don't pay any attention to cary jebus, he/she does not know what he/she is talking about.

I do so, I am just evoleving marxism.

You need to understand the fundamental concepts of Marxist political economy before you can advance it.

oligarch wrote:

You need to understand the fundamental concepts of Marxist political economy before you can advance it.

I do, and I just have a week constitonal view on the labour theory of value.

The government giving people what it thinks they need is what capitalists always misrepresent communism as. You're making their "communism" come true.